American Idol season 23's newest judge, Carrie Underwood, has been struggling to find her footing on the show and despite making some progress, some of these potential replacements could be a better fit for American Idol season 24.

Underwood auditioned for American Idol back in 2004, and she still has a memento from the audition to remember how far she’s come. But that was almost the only thing she took fr

With American Idol Season 23 heating up, 16-year-old Mattie Pruitt is rapidly emerging as a star. Just before her sweet sixteen on April 15, the high school student from Eagleville, Tennessee, stunned the judges and the audience with her passionate rendition of Katy Perry's popular song "Wide Awake".